Is Marius Müller’s distribution really that bad?
Digging into a personal hobby horse
In the recent Stephen Robinson article, I questioned whether Marius Müller has the worst distribution of any goalkeeper ever. A tad extreme I'll grant you but it was fundamentally based on his goal kicks against St. Mirren. See below.
Müller it turns out has the lowest pass completion of any regular goalkeeper in the Premiership but that's perhaps more a reflection of what he's being asked to do rather than his respective merits with his feet. Let's dig in a bit more.
Ten goal kicks, split by half. Aberdeen attack from left to right; numbers follow match order.
First half 7 kicks
14:3526:31317:39419:37522:59627:03735:25
Second half 3 kicks
159:42265:00376:17
Recorded complete 4Incomplete 4Straight out 2
WhoScored event data. AFC1903 Data Hub
The case against
- 54% of his passes find a teammate. That's the lowest of the 12 keepers with 450 minutes or more. Celtic's Viljami Sinisalo completes 87%.
- He loses the ball about 16 times a game. Only St Johnstone's Toby Steward matches that.
- He puts it out of play. In 12 league games, 19 of his long balls have gone straight out for a throw-in, goal kick or corner. That happened in 10 of the 12 games, so this isn't one bad afternoon.
% of passes completed, 2026–27, minimum 450 minutes
SportmonksAFC1903.com
The case for
- He kicks long more than anyone. 63% of his passes are long balls, the highest share in the league. Long balls are contested, so a keeper who hits a lot of them will always have a low completion rate.
- His long balls are among the best in the league. Aberdeen win 39% of them. Only St Mirren's Jacob Chapman and Motherwell's Alex Paulsen do better.
- His short passing is near-perfect. 121 of 124 short passes found a teammate this season.
- No errors leading to a shot. Three keepers have three or more.
% of each keeper’s passes, 2026–27
SportmonksAFC1903.com
% of long balls that found a teammate, 2026–27
SportmonksAFC1903.com
Does he kick it out more than most?
Yes, a bit.
- 6.3 out of play for every 100 long balls. That's the second-highest of any Aberdeen keeper season since 2021–22, behind Kelle Roos in 2022–23.
- Dimitar Mitov managed 3.4 last season.
- Opposing keepers against Aberdeen average 5.1. Müller is above the norm, but not wildly.
per 100 long balls, Aberdeen keepers by season
WhoScored match data. AFC1903 Data HubAFC1903.com
The verdict
- The low completion rate is mostly the plan. A keeper told to go long two times in three will always sit bottom of this table.
- The kicks out of play are on him. That's about one and a half a game, every game, and it's more than his predecessors.
- What changes now: Robinson's side went long from the back. Whoever replaces him decides whether Müller keeps doing it.
Even in that St. Mirren video you can see completion, other than the ones kicked out of the pitch, on the goalkeeper, his job is to put into the area determined by the manager. The structure following that - winning the ball, picking up second balls, is where we judge success. Aberdeen were giving the ball away too often from having possession which puts us back at the Robinson paradox - playing a way not suited to the squad.
Let's see what the next man in decides to do.
How this was measured
- League comparison: Sportmonks season totals for the 12 keepers with 450 league minutes or more, to 7 November 2026.
- Short passes: Müller's passes minus his long balls, game by game (Sofascore stand-in data).
- Out of play: a long ball that fails and is followed straight away by the opponents' throw-in, goal kick or corner. Taken from WhoScored match data for every Aberdeen league game since 2021–22.
- Sources disagree on long balls: Sportmonks has Müller winning 39% of his long balls, the match-by-match data 36%. The ranking holds either way.
Data: AFC1903 Data Hub, updated 9 November 2026.